Serendip is an independent site partnering with faculty at multiple colleges and universities around the world. Happy exploring!

dichotomies

dichotomies

Ariel Skye's picture

Humans create dichotomies to make sense of the world around them. It is our way of simplifying complex entities that bleed together and intersect in surprising (and sometimes inexplicable ways). It is easy to create a distinction between natural and artificial. But then what are artificial products bred out of nature? Are human beings natural? Are man-made products, like a house, natural? Are beaver dams natural? Nothing in our world falls nicely and neatly into one of two categories.


This sort of mindset can quickly become very dangerous, for it elevates one group over another. We’ve seen this detrimental mindset dictate our own human history--man vs. woman, black vs. white, gay vs. straight, etc. Haraway explored the human vs. animal dichotomy and highlighted ways in which it can lead to harmful actions. I really like what tajiboye pointed out: “major "blows" to the importance of humanity have given us even more reason to create a separation between "us" and "them"”. I feel that as humans become more and more aware of our small role within the complex systems of the world, we desperately aim to assert our importance; our significance.

Clarifying

 

Supporting

 

Complexifying

In thinking about Ariel’s post, I wanted to point out the importance of language in dichotomies. Through language we are able to construct these dichotomies, to delineate between certain things that we need to separate to preserve, as Ariel puts it, our human significance. It felt like maybe Coetzee should rejoin the conversation. We talked about his distrust of rants and language and literature. Given the chosen format of Haraway’s book, at first glance I doubt Coetzee and Haraway would agree on many points.

Weaving

 

Challenging

 

Unspecified