Serendip is an independent site partnering with faculty at multiple colleges and universities around the world. Happy exploring!

Being a Skeptic

EVD's picture

After class today I was thinking about how I might apply Sagan's skepticism to my life. I consider myself a pretty skeptical person, especially of authority, but I was trying to think of instances when I might not be skeptical...When I go to the doctor's office and my doctor diagnoses a sickness I might have, I never question her diagnosis as long as I have been thorough in telling her my symptoms. But when I take my dog to the veterinarian I ALWAYS question the vet's diagnosis and course of treatment because I have been a vet tech and know that vets make mistakes and there are always several diagnoses and courses of treatment that a vet might make. The vet could also prescribe treatment just to make extra money. The only reason I question my pet's vet is because I am somewhat knowledgeable about animal health, though obviously not as knowledgeable as a veterinarian. I don't question my own doctor because I don't know much about human health. I think that Carl Sagan would say that I should be skeptical in accepting the opinion of my own doctor even though I don't know much about human medicine. Or would he say that I should become knowledgeable about my illness, even if the illness is very insignificant, so that I have the knowledge to judge my doctor's opinion? Perhaps I would do this if the illness was very serious but not in most cases. I think you could make the same argument about judging the advice of your lawyer or even of a professor who gave you advice about editing a paper...but is this really feasible? No matter how much I try to learn about these things I still won't be as knowledgeable as a person whose profession it is to be knowledgeable about the subject. I think that maybe in these cases there is a difference between an authority figure unknowingly giving incorrect information and an authority figure lying (maybe to charge you more money, avoid work, etc). I guess my conclusion would be that I'm still not really sure what exactly Sagan means by "skepticism" and "questioning authority."

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.
17 + 2 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.