Serendip is an independent site partnering with faculty at multiple colleges and universities around the world. Happy exploring!

Video Games: A Cause of Violence and Aggression

SerendipUpdate's picture

Biology 202
2003 Second Web Paper
On Serendip

Video Games: A Cause of Violence and Aggression

Grace Shin

There is a huge hype surrounding the launch of every new game system - Game Cube, XBox, and Sony Playstation 2 being just few of the latest. Affecting children age 4 all the way to 45 year-old adults, these video games have called for concern in our society regarding issues such as addiction, depression, and even aggression related to the playing of video games. A recent study of children in their early teens found that almost a third played video games daily, and that 7% played for at least 30 hours a week. (1) What is more, some of these games being played like Mortal Combat, Marvel Vs. Capcom, and Doom are very interactive in the violence of slaughtering the opponent. The video game industries even put signs like "Real-life violence" and "Violence level - not recommended for children under age of 12" on their box covers, arcade fronts, and even on the game CDs themselves.

In the modern popular game Goldeneye 007 bad guys no longer disappear in a cloud of smoke when killed. Instead they perform an elaborate maneuver when killed. For example, those shot in the neck fall to their knees and then face while clutching at their throats. Other games such as Unreal Tournament and Half-Life are gorier. In these games when characters get shot a large spray of blood covers the walls and floor near the character, and on the occasions when explosives are used, the characters burst into small but recognizable body parts. In spite of the violence, the violent video games are also the more popular games on the market. (2) When video games first came out, indeed they were addictive... however, there seems to be a strong correlation now between the violent nature of games these days and the aggressive tendencies in game players.

On April 20, 1999, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold launched an assault on Columbine High School in Littleton, Colorado, murdering 13 and wounding 23 before turning the guns on themselves. Although nothing is for certain as to why these boys did what they did, we do know that Harris and Klebold both enjoyed playing the bloody, shoot-'em-up video game Doom, a game licensed by the U.S. military to train soldiers to effectively kill. The Simon Wiesenthal Center, which tracks Internet hate groups, found in its archives a copy of Harris' web site with a version of Doom. He had customized it so that there were two shooters, each with extra weapons and unlimited ammunition, and the other people in the game could not fight back. For a class project, Harris and Klebold made a videotape that was similar to their customized version of Doom. In the video, Harris and Klebold were dressed in trench coats, carried guns, and killed school athletes. They acted out their videotaped performance in real life less than a year later... (3)

Everyone deals with stress and frustrations differently. However when action is taken upon the frustration and stress, and the action is taken out in anger and aggression, the results may be very harmful to both the aggressor and the person being aggressed against, mentally, emotionally, and even physically. Aggression is action, i.e. attacking someone or a group with an intent to harm someone. It can be a verbal attack--insults, threats, sarcasm, or attributing nasty motives to them--or a physical punishment or restriction. Direct behavioral signs include being overly critical, fault finding, name-calling, accusing someone of having immoral or despicable traits or motives, nagging, whining, sarcasm, prejudice, and/or flashes of temper. (4) The crime and abuse rate in the United States has soared in the past decade. More and more children suffer from and are being treated for anger management than ever before. Now, one can't help but to wonder if these violent video games are even playing a slight part in the current statistics. I believe they do.

Calvert and Tan (5) compared the effects of playing versus observing violent video games on young adults' arousal levels, hostile feelings, and aggressive thoughts. Results indicated that college students who had played a violent virtual reality game had a higher heart rate, reported more dizziness and nausea, and exhibited more aggressive thoughts in a posttest than those who had played a nonviolent game do. A study by Irwin and Gross (6) sought to identify effects of playing an "aggressive" versus "nonaggressive" video game on second-grade boys identified as impulsive or reflective. Boys who had played the aggressive game, compared to those who had played the nonaggressive game, displayed more verbal and physical aggression to inanimate objects and playmates during a subsequent free play session. Moreover, these differences were not related to the boys' impulsive or reflective traits. Thirdly, Kirsh (7) also investigated the effects of playing a violent versus a nonviolent video game. After playing these games, third- and fourth-graders were asked questions about a hypothetical story. On three of six questions, the children who had played the violent game responded more negatively about the harmful actions of a story character than did the other children. These results suggest that playing violent video games may make children more likely to attribute hostile intentions to others.

In another study by Karen E. Dill, Ph.D. & Craig A. Anderson, Ph.D., violent video games were considered to be more harmful in increasing aggression than violent movies or television shows due to their interactive and engrossing nature. (8) The two studies showed that aggressive young men were especially vulnerable to violent games and that even brief exposure to violent games can temporarily increase aggressive behavior in all types of participants.
The first study was conducted with 227 college students with aggressive behavior records in the past and who completed a measure of trait aggressiveness. They were also reported to have habits of playing video games. It was found that students, who reported playing more violent video games in junior and high school, engaged in more aggressive behavior. In addition, the time spent playing video games in the past were associated with lower academic grades in college, which is a source of frustration for many students, a potential cause for anger and aggression as discussed in the previous paragraph.

In the second study, 210 college students were allowed to play Wolfenstein 3D, an extremely violent game, or Myst, a nonviolent game. After a short time, it was found that the students who played the violent game punished an opponent for a longer period of time compared to the students who played the non violent game. Dr. Anderson concluded by saying, "Violent video games provide a forum for learning and practicing aggressive solutions to conflict situations. It the short run, playing a violent video game appears to affect aggression by priming aggressive thoughts." Despite the fact that this study was for a short term effect, longer term effects are likely to be possible as the player learns and practices new aggression-related scripts that can become more and more accessible for the real-life conflict that may arise. (9)

The U.S. Surgeon General C. Everett Koop once claimed that arcade and home video games are among the top three causes of family. Although there have been studies that have found video game violence to have little negative effects on their players, there are also many studies that have found a positive correlation between negative behavior, such as aggression, and video and computer game violence. Thus, in order to totally assess the effects of game violence on its users, the limiting conditions under which there are effects must be taken into account, which include age, gender, and class/level of education. (10) However, violent games do affect children, as the studies show, especially early teens, and I feel that there needs to be a stricter regulation regarding the availability of these games to young children.

 

References

1) BBC News Web site in UK.

2) Game Research Website, covering the art, the business, and the science of computer games.

3) American Psychological Association, Article on the main study discussed in this paper.

4) Mental Help Net, Psychological Self-Help. This site has a lot of interesting links to mental illnesses and just understanding personalities.

5) Calvert, Sandra L., & Tan, Siu-Lan. (1994). Impact of virtual reality on young adults' physiological arousal and aggressive thoughts: Interaction versus observation. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 15(1), 125-139. PS 527 971.

6) Irwin, A. Roland, & Gross, Alan M. (1995). Cognitive tempo, violent video games, and aggressive behavior in young boys. Journal of Family Violence, 10(3), 337-350.

7) Kirsh, Steven J. (1997, April). Seeing the world through "Mortal Kombat" colored glasses: Violent video games and hostile attribution bias. Poster presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Washington, DC.

8) SelfhelpMagazine. Article under teen help. It is a great library of various mental disorders and personal growth topics!

9) American Psychological Association.

10) Internet Impact This paper is a collaborative essay consisting of research and policy recommendations on the impact of the Internet in society.

 

 

Continuing conversation
(to contribute your own observations/thoughts, post in the Video Game Experiences Forum on Serendip)

06/21/2005, from a Reader on the Web

According to an article in the New York Daily News http://www.nydailynews.com/06-20-2005/city_life/tech/story/320762p-274211c.html), the latest controversial video game, “25 To Life,” is the most outrageous promotion of violence the game developers have pushed onto the market yet. It’s almost like a training simulator, preparing gamers to join gangs, murder policemen and use innocent civilians as human shields. Let the good times roll, eh? Shockingly enough, I’m a 22-year-old male who considers himself a casual gamer, which probably places me in most game developers’ targeted demographic. Still, I believe this sort of “entertainment” should be banned completely, not just from children. Why should anyone of any age delight in simulating gang activity, murder, theft and the like? Unfortunately Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) stands as the only politician attempting to block “25 To Life” from hitting store shelves. If the Patriot Act brands people terrorists just for checking out certain books at the library, why are people who develop, purchase and play these types of games given a free pass? As a gamer, I know how serious games can become to certain individuals - especially young ones – and I believe allowing material such as “25 To Life” onto the market corrupts not only our children, but our society as a whole. Michael Ford Editor-in-Chief The Voice - http://www.uamont.edu/Organizations/TheVoice/


09/12/2005, from a Reader on the Web

Ignarants is that in which you make of it don't blame Columbine on video games that is stupid they did it because the dudes girl friend broke up with him. Don't read the news they lie. The cop next door knew he was making pipe bombs and did nothing. you might as well blame 9/11 on video games to. come on people play the games if it makes you viloent your right if it doesn't the rest of the world told you so.......


09/27/2005, from a Reader on the Web

I was reading your article entitled Video Games: A cause of Violence and Agression, I'm doing a research project of my own for a personal Essay but upon reading your article I noticed somthing. In paragraph four you state "THe crime and abuse rate in the United States has soared in the past decade." Well, I'm sorry to say this information is faulty. The case of Violent Crime Rates has dropped significantly. According to the U.S Department of Justice, Bureau of statistics, the crime rate has dropped by more then half from 1995 to 2004. You can see all this for youself at: www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/glance/viort.htm . I'm a gamer myself, and a bit tired of seeing these "Video games make you a killer" stories. This isn't a threat against you or yours, it's merely a response asking people to do some research from all angles before stating that something is a certain way. Sincerely,


11/02/2005, from a Reader on the Web

In the article titled "Video Games: A Cause of Violence and Aggression," the study that was sited left me feeling a little confused. The players that played "Wolfenstein 3D" were said to have "punished an opponent for a longer period of time compared to the students who played the non violent game." What exactly is meant by that? In "Myst" there are no opponents, and it is not a competitive game. Competitive events, in any form, have a tendency to cause a bit of agression between people, as that is the nature of competetion.


11/04/2005, from a Reader on the Web

This article is very wrong in alot of places. First off, I would like to say that I am an avid "gamer," devoting a sizeable amount of my life to playing them. But, more importantly, I will be getting into the video game industry, hopefully starting my own company eventually, and succeeding in this million-dollar industry. But more than I play games, I edit them. The sequel to Half-Life (in which all humans retain their body parts), Half-Life 2, comes with a program called "Source SDK," which allows gamers like me to open up and edit the engine that they slaved over for moths to bring us, allowing us to make maps (or levels), characters, objects, even editing the game itself. I spend easily three times the time I play the actual game editing it and making things happen, which is the beauty of it. On your statement about how crime and violence has soared in numbers in the U.S. as of late, this is not a true statement, be it purposefully or a fault of poor research. Violent crimes, carjackings, and others have drastically DROPPED since 1975. I suggest you read the letter Steven Johnston sent to Sen. Hilary Clinton about her attack on violent games. But, as I doubt you will read it, I'll tell you the main points: First off, isn't it possible that kids that would normally be out commiting violent crimes or joyriding are getting their fill from argueably the most violent and inappropriate game of our time, the Grand Theft Auto series? Recent studies have shown that games work as a stress-reliever, allowing you to let out your anger or stress in a realistic but harmless way. Second, when people say that our generation of people (I'm 16 years old) is being raised to be unintelligent, violent, untrusting people, they need to look up on the recent statistics: SAT scores have never been higher, especially now. I'm not saying that there aren't a handful of kids out there who take a little too much from violent games and other forms of entertainment (my brother happens to have an anger disorder), but I am saying that if you even think that your kid may take the game a little too seriously, start smaller and work your way up. Taking violent games off the market completely is not the answer. After all, why should the sane, intelligent, or sound kids have to pay for a parent not saying "No" in the first place?


11/05/2005, from a Reader on the Web

Dear Grace Shin, As a result of reading over my previous e-mail, i'd like to appologize for my use of unnecesary comments. But that doesnt mean that my original views have changed. The original response that was written, was done so in the heat of reading a "finger pointing" article such as the one you wrote. The most blatantly offensive comment that you made, was the tie between the video game 'Doom' and the Columbine trajedy. It is comments like these that are extremely offensive to anyone who is a fan of gaming in general. I am a teenager, who attends a public high school. I enjoy playing video games, and i must admit that most of them are violent. I play these games on a weekly basis, but to this day i haven't commited a single act of violence in a school building. The same holds true with my friends, and many people like my friends across the country. This means that the children who have commited acts of violence and blamed their actions on video games, have other mental illnesses that stir these thoughts. Depression, anger issues and a myriad of other problems would be enough to distort a child's view of the difference between reality and video games. A popular arguement used to counter the arguement i just made, is the scanning of the brain during game play. In tests conducted by various medical institutes across the nation, brain scan images have been captured during game-play. The images are conclusive, and show red blips in the frontal lobes of the brain (areas that control emotions, such as anger). These results shouldnt be shocking, but very obvious. Video games are stimulating. Their purpose and intent is to involve you. If a person is involved in a game, he/she will begin to react to events inside the game, as if they were real life events. Fairly simple, but not enough to prove that video games cause children to become more violent. The way to answer this question would be to observe children's behavior after playing games. The results would aslo be conclusive. Video games DO NOT cause children to commit acts of violence. Columbines' dont happen every day, and thank god they don't. They are rare occurances in our country, despite all of the media hype over the situations. If video games had a negatice affect on children, horrible examples of school-yard violence would appear on our television screens every night, considering that msot youth in america play video games. As a final note, if you search any major database sites, looking for information on this same subject, chances are that you will find line graphs that have been compiled by different government associasions, fcc, etc. etc. The information shows a very steady and gradual dive in violence across the nation, even after the release of video games such as Grand Theft Auto.


11/08/2005, from a Reader on the Web

You cannot generalize the few finds you have to "empirical facts". First of all, video games are not all violent. Second, there are researches that prove otherwise. Third, there are so many fallacies, I do not even bother to list them (appeal to authority, emotion, etc.) Overall argument is incoherent. Fails to even mention the possibility of being wrong.


11/21/2005, from a Reader on the Web

I think its ridiculous that so many people are going around and pointing the finger at things that are violent and negative towards kids. Its only a way of having fun. Only those few individuals take it to far and commite acts of violence toward people, and society, and they ruin it for the rest of us. Not everyone that plays video games is a violent person they merely enjoy those types of games like my self for example. I personally am not a voilent person and take offense to the fact that if u play video games you are labeled violent. Sincerly, RB


11/27/2005, from a Reader on the Web

As a gamer I know that certain people take there video games too seriously. However, video games themselves are not to blame for violence. The highest population of gamers is younger people, and younger people are usually living at home. This is where parenting comes in. A parent should watch there children, monitor there game play, and note any variances in there childrens actions. Some people cannot decipher fantasy from reality, and these should people not play games that involve violence. I have played video games for many, many years. I have not yet comitted a violent crime, nor have I attacked anyone. Why? Simply because I know that these things are wrong in real life. My parents monitored me, and did not let me play overly-violent games at a young age. Good parenting is the key.


12/01/2005, from a Reader on the Web

I was reading your article and I'm sorry, but I disagree with you on some things. I'm 17 years old and a gamer myself. I own some gory games like the Silent Hill games, Metal Gear 3: Snake Eater, God of War, HALO, HALO 2, and so on. I'm currently writing a paper myself about teens and violent games and I firmmly believe it isn't the video game that triggers teen violence, it depends on the individual. I've played these violent games since I was 11 or 12 years old and I'm not affected by them. I have a strong sense between fantasy and reality and some other teens do too. Don't judge us all because a portion of us have minds like sponges and suck everything they see. Not only video games, MTV and the media along with rap songs also corrupt our young generation. Look at those too, because they're the ones that cause the most damage. By encouraging pre-marital sex, abortion, drug use, and corruption in a person's being by being "cool". But no, not a lot of people look at those. It is true that games can be addicting but not every single teenager has the same brain. Study those who aren't affected, then you'll see it too. Adults can stop teen violence other ways like better parenting. Because this corrupted society needs it.


12/08/2005, from a Reader on the Web

I am writing a paper concerning violence in video games and how easy kids are able to get there hands on them. It is unbelievable what games that kids at the age of tweleve can get there hands on. once when i was babing sitting the kids had a friend over and there friend had Grand theft Auto: San Andras with him. i was shocked for the first part that his parents would allow him to play such game. he had saved game file on which he had played for many 20 hours. That was kid that was under 10. I thought why in the world would you allow your kids to play a such game. one problem with it is that game like GTA and others never really so some of the peprecuctions of murdering someone of killing them. If look that most gamers that are over the age of 18. under 50% of them play games that are rated M. That says that most of people playing games that are rated M are below age 18 not even legal to buy them. The government need to come out with laws simlar to laws they have with Alcohol or Cigerettes. The giving to minors is illegal.


12/12/2005, from a Reader on the Web

Interesting analysis on the societal impact of violent games. I do, however, take issue with the statement regarding the military using Doom to train soldiers how to "effectively kill". According to the official MCMSMO document 1500.55, the use of Marine Doom and other first-person shooter video games is to "implement military thinking and decision making excercises throughout the marine corps." The assertion that the military uses a video game to train soldiers how to kill is misleading in that it may lead readers to believe that these games are so real that the best fighting force on the planet is using it to train. You don't learn how to kill from a keyboard and mouse. You either are someone who has the ability to kill, or you're not. Lack of parenting and a lack of understading of what is right and wrong is to blame, not video games.


12/14/2005, from a Reader on the Web

Your idealalidgy on the violence in video games affeting people is flawed. I am a violent video game player and yet my family has told me themselves that have noticed a change in my temper or personality. I've played violent video game for half my life. And the Columbine shootings I belive that they were provoced to do to extrem bullying.

 

Additional comments made prior to 2007
Will i think that children playing violent video games should not be allowed. The industries that makes this games are basically marketing murder. Industries acknowledge that their games are inappropriate for children but then why aren't they accepting regulations of the sale of their products to children. Video games are just as bad as smoking, and alcohol it is harmful. These industries just want MONEY and their games do influence children ... Lynne Maraha, 8 March 2006

i'm a more than average gamer.. i probably play about 10+ hours a day. and about 100% of the games i play are violent, and i used to live in an area that was really rough and there were fights and arguments all the time. except i never shot anyone or drove my truck over people. cause violent cideo games dont make people into pyscho's... people 'choose' to hurt other people... videogames dont force people to pull the trigger. and since i was raised by a single parent, tv and games helped raise me.

actually i think video games kept me outta trouble... if i didnt have a video-game to play i'd probably be getting stoned or smoking crack right now.. or in jail. i think the government needs to crack down on illegal drugs and on finding cure's for diseases... why the hell would you spend 90 million dollars to start research on the effect of media on children ... Reader on the web, 14 March 2006
Dear Writer. No offense but some of your information is wrong. And please andswer me this in the 19th Century Waltz music was outlawed as evil incarnate. But over the years it has become one of the major money making industries. Now im sure that even you enjoy some music. My point being gaming is going down the same road. Will it take 100 years for people to change their mind. I bloody hope not! These games insipired me to begin on my own book. Gaming can be evil but most children, even the younger ones, shrug it off as " Interesting but not real." I hope my comments helped change your mind, most critics of gaming never play so how can you critisize ... Erik, 21 March 2006
I am a gamer and beilieve that the parenting matters the most. I and many others play video games to do things that we would never do in real life. They are an escape from the real world. In some cases they prevent me from doing wrong in real life. They do effect you after a long long time. The bible says what comes in must come out and I am a strong believer in that. but that is for prolonged exposures to violene. but me I can tell between games and reality. If I am angry, I will play Halo 2 to get the anger out. It helps me not comit a crime and to keep my cool. Colombine was the parents fault not games. kids also must have picked on them alot. that dosnt excuse there actions though. Do you play violent games. I bet you dont. Then dont judge what they do to you untill you have. you have no position in the argument unless you have ... Reader on the web, 21 March 2006
I am 15 years old and i am a gamer. I think that you are right yet wrong at the same time. I am doing an essay on whether or not I think that violent video games affect childrens decision to join a gang or commit violent crimes. I have one thing to sum it up. Sure video games are violent but can they load a gun and pull the trigger for you? Can they pull out your pocket knife and stab someone for you. Video games may have an affect on children BUT THEY CANNOT FORCE SOMEONE TO PULL THE TRIGGER ... James S, 28 March 2006
dear mrs. shin
i believe that although you present a good argument about how games MIGHT affect a child's brain and personality, but, you must realize this. if you TRULY believe that video games cause violence, then how would you be able to explain Hitler? how about Napoleaon? Or even the terrorists that many of our youth's games depict today? i highly doubt that any of the insurgents are playing any violent games right now. nor, i doubt, even the Children of iraq and afghanistan, yet studies show that 1 out of 3 children in those countries know how to shoot and kill U.S soldiers. thank you for your time and please take this to heart before writing any thing that might be untrue ... Reader on the web, 20 April 2006
everything today has been considered or is being considered violent. Video games do show violence but do not provoke it. there have been more violent crimes due to sports rather than video games. Take soccer games in south america, when ever a team looses the fans become angry and violent just like in any other sport (video games aswell). But when have you seen Riots occur due to a person loosing or seeing violence in video games? Riots arent rare in south america due to hooligans and hardcore fans. Sure in very few cases people commit violent crimes after playing video games but riots due to sports have causes many many deaths and injuries over the years and still continue to this day, are they considering banning them aswell? I play video games daily but sports aswell and in sports such as football... we take the anger out on the other player by tackling them or clippin em.. and people do brake bones or get head injuries while in video games the only person getting hurt is the damn 3D animated creature or human. If they try to ban video games they'd might aswell ban sports while they are at it ... Ale, 12 May 2006

 

 

I play violent video games and my family has yet to say I am more aggresive in personality. But you still have a point since i'm me and the people who are influenced to kill by video games are them. The point is that all you have to do is to not become obsessed with games that have lots of gore ... Decoy, 20 August 2006

 

 

I love playing video games on my game console, and spend plenty of hours perched in front of the tv. Yet even i have to acknowledge that games can, and do cause violence. When you have games that are so graphic, that had they been put in a movie sequence their rating would be "x", then i think that you have gone to far. Life like graphics are cool, and i myself love to play "life like" games were the enemies and characters could almost be standing beside you. However, when you go around in a game killing these life like people, you enevitably desensitize yourself. There is a mark where you have gone too far, and i believe that we are crossing it over and over again ... Rae, 18 December 2006

 

 

Well. I ccame here looking for statistics but instead found a lot of interesting comments.

Playing video games doesn't make you violent. Human nature and suceptibility does. Violence is a "learned" behavior not substantialy (as of yet but to be determined) an inherent behavior.

If thats not in the report or whatever up there, then it needs to be acknoledged. The point a LOT of people gloss over is that its not a matter of \"being\" violent so much as being impressionable. Although gaming related violence research HAS shown there to be a strong coorelation between agressive behaviour and post-gaming violent behavior, there is a distinct lack of longitudinal research.

Also there are two main aspects to clinical study Arousel, and then the actual comission of the act. Arousel has been shown to have almost no bearing on the actual act due to the fact that observe violent behavior has not occured directly after the moment of arousel.

In other words, just because you enjoy the violent activity of a game, doesn't mean you ARE violent at all OR because of the game. What is being studied is that statistical occurance of agressive behavior in people with prolonged exposure to violent games.

If you've played video games you know that 1. Some games are violent. 2. Some aren't.

I noticed some of you have acknowledged the "competative" nature of video games. This learned sense of competition is fine but is not to be associated with "agressive behavior" there is a distinct line between number of goals and number of frags. The issue is the Violence, not the the rules.

In summary I say to all who worry about being accused of being "violent": Don't sweat it and don't get your hackles raised. The debate is over the usual badd apples, or kids who didn't and thus still do't, have the right behavioral reinforcement. Ideal preventive measures start from birth, but practicly are documented to be administered from age 8 and continue through adolescence.

To put it in a lay manner: Its because of the tools, that our favorite games are being attacked. And as an afterthought. The group who were studied playing the game "Myst"(if that was the case) was most likely a control group or a "backlight" group to help identify the differences between violent games and games in general, OR violence free games ... W. Caudill, 16 February 2007

 

 

I, for one, am one of the many teens that play violent video games. And, i do beleive that cause aggrivation to sprout betweent to people versing each other. Also that MMORPG's cause people to have a sense of connection to their character, making them rather play, for instance, World of Warcraft than doing academic work. Plus when parents are trying to get their teen children off a game they tend to be rather aggresive torwards the parents and are moody for ahwile. Thus i do beleive that video games are a cause of violence but it's not entirely the kids fault, the parents are the one that beleive there kids are able to handle it and don't think there "Little Angels" can handle it. Well i have news for those parents, " Watch the violence in the games you get your children and i can gaurentee you will change you mind about letting them play rated M games!" ... Reader on the Web, 18 March 2007

 

 

First of all I believe that your study is incredibly flawed, and the only conclusion that can be made from it (Myst has less opponents than Wolfenstein)has NOTHING to do with the original arguement. The arguments concerning the "Doom used as a training tool" and Wolfstein vs. Myst are completely misleading and efected in all ways by your bias opinion. Also, your connection with the shootings to videogames is only a coincedence, in that it may have nothing to do with the shootings ... Joey, 1 May 2007

 

 

On Your paper Video Games: A Cause of Violence and Aggression, i have to say this. I'm an avid gamer myself, and, though I cannot speak for everyone,I,nor anyone I play with has any problems with agression. sure games can be addicting, as well as extremely violent but in many cases I feel much less agressive after playing games like HALO and DOOM. As for Cases like Cho and the colombine shooters, if you know that you or someone close to you could be a sociopath or homicidal, they shouldn't be near games like these anyway. However, Ms. Shin, i do agree that some games are too violent. games like the GTA series and 25 to Life strongly suggest that killing innocent people and Authority figures are perfectly ok. This is completely and totally wrong, and needs more backing. My final coment to everyone, game-manufacturers especially, WATCH WHAT IS IN THESE GAMES, if we con tinue this way, our worst fears may be realized ... Tyler Hale, 3 December 2007

 

 

You Fail! Some video games are violent by nature. If you were to tell the story of World War II without violence and death, it becomes totally uninteresting. Much of the violence in games comes from the story, like Halo puts the player into the shoes of a soldier in the Marines! Also, the armed forces of the United States developed their own training game. It was then repackaged and TONED DOWN for the public, but does that train people to kill? NO. Why does propaganda seem to always be excluded? ... Greg, 4 December 2007

Comments

Anonymous's picture

i have done an experiment my

i have done an experiment my self with vioent videogames, movies,and music. 1 person was playing vioent videogames 1 person was watching violent movies/tv shows and 1 person was listining to violent music and the i did the oppocite with 3 people and saw that vioent videogames, movies, and music do cause aggression but very little. Also their personality made a big difference. People who are extremely angry tend to be much more affected by violent videogames than people who are not angry and of course the opposite is true.

Eric's picture

Videogames may cause violent thoughts but...

we have to realize that if you play a videogame, you are not autoamtically a school shooter or a thug. Videogames teach kids and teens violent ways to solve their problems, and in games like GTA when it's easy to escape authority, it makes violence seem like a logical way to solve a problem

Anonymous's picture

I have a question. When they

I have a question. When they did these studies, were the people being studied playing video games when they were being studied, because then these conclusions make perfect sense. If you're doing something that requires you to be aggressive, such as, fighting, watching violent tv, or even reading violent or suspense filled books, you're heart rate and aggression are definitely going to rise. The real question is do they make people commit real world violence. I think that most of the blame lies with parents. Back when cartoons like Tom and Jerry, and Quick Draw McGraw were popular, you didn't see people shooting each other in the face, because they thought all that would happen is black smoke would get on their face did you? That's because back then parents took the time to teach kids not to do things like that, because the results are different from cartoons. Kids need to be taught the difference between real and fantasy violence.

Panther's picture

Its the player

Im a pretty common gamer and are not a violent person, i think it all comes down to the player, monkey see monkey do, im smart enough to know what belongs in the game and what is acceptable in real life

BraverThought's picture

Worse research ever, someone should be fired!!

Violence has been around for thousands of years. Why? Could it be greed? Fighting over land or property, food, gold, Religion? Fighting because of jealousy? Maybe there are more violent crimes these days compared to those days cause.... there are billions of more people on this planet.

I have played video games for 15 years now and I am not violent. In fact, by playing games like "Halo" online and using a headset to communicate as a team has given me an amazing communication skill. By playing games such as "Starcraft", I can multi-task very well with little to no stress. By playing,.. really any and every game has increased coordination. By playing PC games, my typing skills and ten key are well above average. Their are many other benefits to playing video games whether it be a violent or nonviolent game.

"Doom", Anyone who has ever played "Doom" knows that if you see an enemy on your screen and you pull the trigger you will hit the enemy, it has no training value what so ever to it. Not to mention that the enemies are mostly crazy looking monsters all bulgy and crappy pixel quality. So again no training value what so ever.

The people I see get violent are the people that get the shit kicked out of them growing up, they form a psychological issue from that.

Humans are not the only living thing on this planet that is violent. Pit bulls don't play video games.

:Gangs were not formed based on video games.
:Wars were not started over a match of 007.
:Rape is not the cause of a 10 year old playing pac man.
:A bee will not sting you because halo exists.

If you want to do some research read these comments on this page, Its a list of individuals that have played video games, and all feel that this article is ridicules. If your going to say that Columbine was caused by them playing doom, than you need to explain how such a thing could occur. Otherwise there isn't any proof to give you any right to say it influenced their decision to do what they did.

Maybe research those that are in jail/prison and see if forcing them to play some "dora dora"/"barbie" video games will make them nonviolent, Get them out side and have them play tag your it. And duck duck goose. That will really get their spirits up.

What is your point when saying violent games cause the heart to beat faster than non violent games... Its the anticipation so to say that cause's the heart to beat faster, like a golfer making a 40 ft putt.

I have never herd anyone say "Call of duty" isn't real enough and that they were enrolling into the military to go to war.

I would say that priests raping little kids in REAL LIFE is a concern, not violence in a FANTASY world called a video game.

Anonymous's picture

Video games

I'm an avid 16 year old gamer. Sure you can 'cop' out and blame every violent act you witness and hear on video games, But you're just making yourself blind to real matter. Kids who end up shooting up a school or killing someone have serious pyschologicl issues that can't even begin to be blamed on something as minuite as video games. You have to take into consideration thier home life and social interaction.

I won't say though that violence in video games won't desentisize you, because I personally believe it does. But anything you witness that is considered violence will desentisize, not just video games.

I believe video games can be used as a very good learning tool also.

Anonymous's picture

im with you

im with you

strategy games's picture

This is not the case with

This is not the case with every video game user, i think on the moral front the responsibility has to be taken by the parents to check the timings when children's are sticking to the video game or else also to check the types of games they are playing,like war games and fighting games among the kids are very popular.but also there are some strategy games which helps their mental development.

Anonymous's picture

violent video games do not caused violence

i am a 17 and i have been playing violent video games since i was 2 and i am not violent. First of all in the beginning, the main reason why (probably) they killed many people and then themselves is probably so they can become famous. In order to be violent and act out something in a video game, they first must have that idea in their head. Then they go out, buy a violent video game, play it, study it, then act it out. Then video game it self did not cause them to become violent! Also i know several investigators (5 to be exact) that play HALO a video game that involves shooting other players and is under the catagory as violent and they are not violent at all. They have never killed any body in their whole life and i should know b/c i asked. Also if you have researched anything in ur whole life you would see that since the first violent video games came out, violent crimes have gone down. People that go out and act out a video games in real life just want fame. People are just blaming video games b/c deep down inside they were already violent, even before they got the game!

Anthony's picture

You asked them?

You asked people if they've ever killed someone???? Jesus your neighborhood is really open XD

Sarah's picture

Video Games and Violence

I work at a well known video game store and I can tell you straight up that your generalization of video gamers being violent is wrong. I've yet to meet single person who is violent in that store. I am a gamer myself and I play Halo, Resident Evil, Left 4 Dead, No More Heroes, and other such "violent" games. These people that go crazy and kill others, steal things, and even decide to burn down buildings cannot be blamed on video game violence. If you cannot tell the difference between a video game and reality then you have a mental illness that needs to be solved. These people point their fingers towards video games yet more than 72% of Americans play video games and you don't see them out on the street killing and maiming people. Parents and the media are just blaming video games for the violence that might occur in children because parents are lacking these days in parenting skills. Kids can't be spanked because that is abuse, if they are put in timeout it is neglect, and if they go to bed without supper you better bet that the parent is going to get in trouble. Society puts unfair restrictions on parenting and then expects the children to be perfect. And when it all goes downhill who is to blame? The video games that the parent's couldn't refuse their children because their kids would throw a fit and there was nothing they could do to stop them. People need to see that violence isn't caused by video games. After all people didn't play video games in WWII, and when was the last time you saw a mob boss play a video game? I'm sure as hell Hitler never played! But these are some of the most violent people the world has ever seen...how did they get this way? One thing is for sure...it wasn't video games.

Anonymous's picture

hey

you make a really good point but have you even stop to think that maybe some people do get there ideas from video games,movies,tv,ect. That they dont act this way at your store but they can act this way outside your shore.Pepole dont notice the little thing but they always let the big thing bother them.If you even get a chance stop and listen as you watch the little things go by. you may realize and open your eyes to a differnt posibility in the way you think about video games and how they may noit effect you and other around you injinally, but the could effect us outside your store,ect. because we could get our ideas from the video games,movies and ect.

Anonymous's picture

right

i so totaly agree with u man lady who ever u r

Anonymous's picture

Come on

Don't be biased. Don't have any pre-conceived opinion before you read my comment. You are undecided right now on this topic. Those people killed a lot of innocent kids in Columbine. Hitler killed 6,000,000 innocent jews. Some people are insane. Video games have no effect of that. The shooter from Columbine played video games. I play video games. He shot people. I won't. Done.

Cheshire Cat's picture

video games a cause of violence and agresion

I am a 18 year old girl and I have ben playing video games since I was a little kid around 5 or 6. my mental stability is just fine, infact i am going to coledge to be a "shrink", and what i have found is that if a person allredy has a mental illness then a violent video game could be the thing that pushes them over the edge or helps them plan out their violent act. BUT if the video game didnt push them that last mile it would be somthing elce. trust me i know a lot of crazy people. violent video games dont turn a normal kid into pysco killers you have to look at all the contributing factors. i.e. do they have a good home life, wer they abused, are they prone to violence, wer they tought good values, ect. you get the point, i just wish "educated" people (being sarcastic there guys) would stop pointing theyr fingers a video games for the dumb things stupid pysco people do. its not just the game industrys that get the bable its us gamers too. some people are saying things like "oh she plays video game, dont let jimmy hang out with her he could get hert". i don't know about you guys but that just rubs me the wrong way. but i'll sut up now thanks.
p.s most of the spelling and gramer wazz on purpose.(big Smiles)

Anonymous's picture

i agree with this

i agree that video games do cause violence but i also agree that bad parenting is also a worse case of violence. i have played video games before and that last couple of times i have played i got into trouble after playing. the times i didn't get into trouble then i regretted playing the video game cuz to me it felt like i just wasted all that time playing a video game and that i could have done something more productive with my time. i know playing video games is fun because i've played them before. i am also doing a research paper on video games. not necessarily the violence video games cause but also some other things that video games cause. the few things that i found that video games cause are seizures, headaches, and brain damage were the most common causes from playing video games. when you read this you might think whatever but my own cousin has gotten a seizure from playing video games. even if playing video games doesn't effect you enough for you to notice doesn't mean its not effecting you. video games can effect you in more ways then just violence. the most common effect from video games especially the newer ones are headaches. so all you video gamers out there that read this just think and i'll bet that when you play video games then around atleast half the time you get a head ache and for alot of you probably even more then half.
i hope you keep this in mind and it makes you at least not play video games as much.

Anonymous's picture

Invalid.

I must say that your statements are some what wrong. Headaches dont occur in many people only in few cases. and you may think im just pulling this outta my head but me and my friends have played xbox for 36 hours straight. i know most people think thats sad but we have done it, wasnt the greatest time but it happened, and no headaches seizures or anything. I have a friend who had a seizure playing guitar hero but this was because he had an undiagnosed medical condition Epilepsy. Most kids know when they have played video games too long and i think that there are greater things in the world causing violence in kids. Everything causes violence, its our nature...but video games arent to blame.

Monie F Babi's picture

VIOLENT VIDEO GAMES MY SCHOOL PROJECT

WELL I THINK
THAT SINCE VIOLENT VIDEO GAMES HAVE SUCH AN EFFECT
ON MINORS AND TEENAGERS
HOW BOUT THE PARENTS DONT BUY THEM TYPE OF GAMES FOR THEIR CHILDREN
DONT PEOPLE THINK THAT
THE REASON PEOPLE MAKE VIOLENT VIDEO GAMES
BECAUSE THEY WERE INFLUENCED BY WHAT IS ALREADY HAPPENING OUT IN THE WORLD
THEY HAD TO GET THE IDEA FROM SOMEWHERE
SO I BLAME IT ON THE PARENTS

Anonymous's picture

wrong

im sorry but video games never cause violence, ever! columbine had nothing to do with video games. just because they acted it out in a short film about doom does not mean video games are the cause of their actions. they amde that video because they liked violence, killing had an appeal to them, and doom had that violence, so naturally they were drawn to it. you may be thinking this is a bad thing, but it is not. doom was completely unrelated in the killings. first off they were pretending to be part of the matrix, and secondly they were killing the people that had tormented them their entire lives. they were killing the people that had put them down, the people that had picked on them, and the people that had hurt them. you want to know the cause of violence? it is people like you. people that are scared of things they dont understand. people that blame these things for all their problems. how do you think wars are started? people being afraid of other cultures, being uncomfortable with them, and misunderstanding their actions. how do you think the holocaust happened? people misunderstood the jews, they blamed the jews for their social problems, using singular examples to portray all jews as evil and corrupt. dont say that this is differant because it isnt. it is exactly the same thing. this is whats happening to gays right now. people dont understand them and are thus afraid of them, denying them the same rights as ordinary people in EXACTLY the same way as rights were denied to black people, even right down to marriage. to me, when people say video games cause violence it is like they are saying jews are evil or blacks shouldnt be allowed to marry whites, and i have feelings no less strong about it.

Anonymous's picture

I think that these video

I think that these video games are up to the consumer and that there are some cases where people will become attached to video games because they have a mental issue or problem and will then use video games as a way to vent their anxiety around them. I am personally someone that plays a lot of video games and my personal favorite is Counterstrike, where your objective is to kill terrorists or counterterorists. In the end education will allow someone to make a better descision and it may not be the best one all the time but it will make things a lot better for everyone.

Alyssa (16, avid gamer)'s picture

Blame game?

It seems that people always need to put the blame on something for violence.
Sure, there are statistics proving that there are increased levels of agression in gamers, but there are also statistics proving that violence has dropped since the 90's and other statistics against the links of violence and games. In my opinion, it all depends on the people. I'm a gamer and i do like playing violent games (the first game i go to play in an arcade after DDR is House of the Dead or Time Crisis). I play games such as Halo, Call of Duty, Persona, and No More Heroes. But that doesn't make me a violent person. It depends on if the person knows the limits of reality and the game and if they decide to act negatively upon the violence they've witnessed. And for the people that blame the industry...thats why they make ratings. If kids choose to buy games they shouldnt play, then fine. Don't start attacking the industry. The parents should stop their children from buying or playing these games if they feel so strongly.

As an avid gamer and someone who wants to get into the industry, i'd have to say that video games dont cause violence because they're stress relief for people. They help as a release for some anger. Heck, if I have a bad day, I'll turn on my PS2 and play Koei's Dynasty Warriors for a couple hours to release any stress i have.

I have read through both sides of the story, don't take me wrong. I'm doing a report on this subject for my theology class. These are just my views as stated on facts from my life and from the different facts i've read through.

KiannaBby<3(:'s picture

I SO AGREE.

Alyssa is totally right. Parents shouldjust take away the game and be happy. Its total bullcrap.

Anonymous's picture

Did you even read what Alyssa

Did you even read what Alyssa wrote? You just said you agreed with Alyssa however, you said the opposite of what Alyssa was trying to prove. What you said Kianna doesnt make since.

Kendall's picture

the unbiased truth

im not going to say that video games are completely responsible for the large scale and often horrendous violence seen in society.BUT to be fair, one must notice that it has to take some of the blame, firstly behaviour is not inherited but can only be learned, this is why children are susceptible to any and everything. It is beyond me why anyone would want to recreate violence on such a scale and be condoned by the general public but when these acts happen in the "real world" are appalled and disgusted and wondering how something so gruesome could be carried out?
Humans are flawed beings and subject to creating flawed inventions (however well intentioned they are), is it enough to sit back and say there's not enough conclusive evidence to prove that they are somewhat responsible so i will wait until something horrible does happen to do something? how many more children do you wish to see in prison before proper legislatives are put in place to correct the issue.
do some of you know that some of these games aren't just created but are engineered to trigger endorphins in the brain to make them more addictive, and the more addicted one gets to something,the more one idolizes it (and protect it if it is threatened,like the teenaged boy who killed his parents because they took away his Xbox).Many of you would say that there are plenty of non-violent games out there but they aren't the ones that receive the huge amounts of media coverage or the money fueled by million dollar corporations.
again i must reiterate that im not saying that video games are the completely and utterly responsible, i'm saying that many of us need to wake up and realise that this invention isn't so innocent either.

CapCaveman!'s picture

Contradicting Yourself

Your fist and last phrases are contradictory.

"to be fair, one must notice that it has to take some of the blame" Ok true... but then again to be fair, one must notice that ANYTHING has to take blame. What do I mean? Well turn on the news, what do you get? VIOLENCE. Open a newspaper and what do you get? VIOLENCE. Read a book, and what do you get? VIOLENCE. My point is... violence is everywhere. We have access to it in many different formats. Parenting is the key.

"It is beyond me why anyone would want to recreate violence on such a scale and be condoned by the general public but when these acts happen in the "real world" are appalled and disgusted and wondering how something so gruesome could be carried out?" See my response above.

"how many more children do you wish to see in prison before proper legislatives are put in place to correct the issue." How do you recomend we solve the issue? By taking away parents job? No. Parents have to step up to the plate and PAY ATTENTION TO THEIR OWN KIDS. No one else is responsible for raising other peoples children.

"some of these games aren't just created but are engineered to trigger endorphins in the brain to make them more addictive" Very very true. Yet sex also triggers endorphins, and probably on a much higher level. Yet people are not addicted to sex and don't go killing over it ( I'm speaking on a grand scale here - average humans ). So should we ban sex also because its addictive and it can lead "some" misguided souls to act irrationaly? NO! We must educate our children about sex and violence so that they are prepared to UNDERSTAND and recognize the benifits and concequences of their actions. But trying to censor sex and violence has only led to children finding other means of getting this knowledge. So now parents acctualy loose the ability to properly teach their child.

I could go on but... I digress!

Mom of 7's picture

all games

The games DO NOT CAUSE VIOLENCE.It is complete boredom that these kids cause trouble and their PARENTS have not given them the time of day to show them things that they could do positively---like video games.All of my children have pretty good grades in school-AB students.And all of them play the video games.It does not create them to do violence, it lets them get the aggression out in a positive way.And most of all it is fun to them.And best of all I know where they are.At home safe and sound.Millions of people are playing these games,but you dont see millions out there killing and hurting others--unless theyre in the military.Condoned by our government.If my 7 yr old wants to play violent video games Im going to let him.Its not shame on the parents for condoning violence-it should be shameful to the government to promote and cause violence.And lets not forget the gun makers shame on them too.

Anonymous's picture

Preach It!!!

Preach It Mom of 7!!!!! YEAH!!!!! (i wish my mom would think like you)

Intellectualist's picture

Violence caused by the GAME? Really?

I find it very disheartening that people still have failed to realize that a game by itself cannot cause someone to go out and attack or even kill someone. Furthermore, most of the cases involving adolescents or children in violent activities have on been linked to video games because those who are responsible for that child cannot comprehend that either they have made a mistake in raising their child or the child had some pre-existing mental condition. This entire controversy requires people to sit down and analytically process it.

Here is a scenario:

You have just finished playing DOOM. Yes the game was gory you killed many many zombies. Blood went everywhere and it was so fun! Then you come to the conclusion hey this would be fun to do in real life! Maybe I'll go try killing someone tomorrow at school.

Now think about this logically. You are a normal person, you have no mental conditions and play video games for entertainment or to escape from your boring everyday routine. After playing a violent game or watching a violent movie, do you ever get the urge to go kill or violent attack someone? No, This is because you are normal and have no pre-existing conditions you understand that the game if fictional and nothing in the game can happen in real life. You understand the law and know that if you violate it you will be punished and you are HUMAN meaning you cannot just kill someone unless you are in a very desprate or life threatening situation. If it was true that video games cause people to become more violent then why don't we have millions of people running around attack and killing for fun? because normal people don't have the pre-existing conditions the neccessary components to trigger this type of reaction. Simply put, Games are tools for entertainment, we buy them, we use them. Games do NOT have enough influence on the human mind to cause them to lose touch with reality unless they already had a condition that was agrevated by gaming.

Gamer_420's picture

First off, this is why

First off, this is why we have rating on games. If it is rated M, it is not supposed to be played by kids under the age of 17. SO why the fuck are we testing second graders. Fuck, I didn't even know how to play video games that young. Also, the case of the students in Columbine is just a bad case. They had a mental issue, which caused their attack. It wasn't Doom, or anything else. Should we look at all the shit they did and ban that too? They brushed their teeth? Hmm... maybe that's a sign of a killer then, right? Don't be stupid. Movies have ratings, and you wouldn't let a second grader watch a porno, now would you? Be REALISTIC.

Anonymous's picture

I agree

about 75% of my games are first-person shooter, yet i kept my gpa a range of 3.9

Anonymous's picture

Not true..... I have like 50

Not true.....
I have like 50 violent games and im a straight a student and im no violent....

Anonymous's picture

well it depends if ur

well it depends if ur addicted

Anonymous's picture

its bad kno one deserves to

its bad kno one deserves to die over a 17 month old girl knocking over a controller.. and than killing your 17 month old daughter... i think they should abanned it.. the violence in video games.

brmonkey's picture

?

what are you talking about?

Anonymous's picture

I'm doing a research paper

I'm doing a research paper on video games and i'v found that it depends on what game your playing and how mature you are.

clip120's picture

Video games do not promote violence...

I do not agree that video games cause violence because for one, if your old enough and are playing games like halo 3, killzone 2, or world of warcraft then you should know better that what takes place in games like these do not happen in real life, sure some people may think they do but in my opinion there is something wrong with that person, maybe a sickness. I am aware that kids under the age of the recommended age play these games; I meet them on xbox live all the time, but I blame the parents who buy these games for kids under the age. Sure the parents are not in control of the child's actions but still, read the rating before you buy the game. As far as the one guy who thought he was playing halo during laser tag and thought he was hitting the "B" button for bashed and bashed his friend, that guy needs to take a long long break from halo cause that is way too much halo play.

Anonymous's picture

yall crazy

yall is crazy now i thoink that video games is sumtimes the reason why kidds are badd

BraverThought's picture

take candy from a kid, see

take candy from a kid, see how he acts.... BAN CANDY

Anonymous's picture

Video games dont promote violence

they dont they are stress releivers!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i have yet to go on a killing spree and i play Halo 3 Grand Theft Auto 4 have i killed anyone no....

Anonymous's picture

sooo true

hahahaha this is oo true. my friend had been playing halo 3 every day for a month straight. later when he went to laser quest with a group of friends he somehow bashed one them because he was so used to it. also there was this thing i read in the news about 2 kids who were playing a racing game and then went outside to streetrace and hit a taxi and killed the driver.

Anonymous's picture

I have read many journals

I have read many journals and internet sites, etc. on this argument and not that the argument itself isn't important-I'm doing my research paper on it-but what is with all the terrible grammar? That just drives me insane. I know people are busy but just take the extra second and check your spelling and grammar. By the way I am fifteen and no one I know has become violent after playing violent games but my argument is that they do. Constant day after day playing will eventually desensitize you to all the blood and gore, leading you (by you I mean the player) to believe that such actions are A. The games fault, B. Acceptable, or C. Not Inappropriate. So my generalized theory in all of this is "It makes crazy people crazier." That is totally my quote and if you (the reader) want to use it in your revolutionary paper that proves that video games have an effect of unstable people then be my guest, just reference me. (Kleszewski)

Bart's picture

I do not believe that video

I do not believe that video games cause violence. Although it does cause frustration i would never want to harm anyone. Plus, if i throw the remote on the floor(which i almost never do anyway) i would be angry with myself and not with someone else. Video games are there so that you can learn how to control your anger and learn from your mistakes. Maybe parents should not leave their children with games such as GTA, thats true. However, whats important is that the child is aware of where their limits reach in the real world.
I Hope it occurs to everyone that video games are only there to entertain us and not for anything else. Acts of violence are commited by his or her own will and not by the daily interactions with video games.
P.S written by a 14 year old.
Bart

Chauncey's picture

It like this im a naturally

It like this im a naturally violent person so i play video games to avoid getting in trouble in real life and it works. just like as how i teenager am also a horny person i do not just go out and rape chicks despite the fact i could i just masturbate. being a human means thinking about your situation then coming for ways to get around it hence we develop.

LI LI LA LO SORRY CANT TELL YOU  MY NAME's picture

i agree with u im doing a

i agree with u im doing a project on it and i know a lot of close bffl's of mine slowly becoming monsters i really miss how they were before i just wish that people never invented video games..........im not a gamer and my parents dont allow me to play much even though their nonviolent i know there just doing it for my health and yeah....well i love your website well TTFN bye!!!!!

Tim 's picture

This is for all the people

This is for all the people who think GTA is nothing but violence and evil and may hasten the end of the world . lol

1. I'm almost certain that most of you have never even been in a room while another person plays it ( much less play it yourselves ).
2. I'm also almost certain that 90% of what people say about it is just repetitions of what others have said.
3. I AM certain that I have never saw anyone mention the fact that possible sources of income in that extremely evil video game world includes : being a paramedic (getting people to hospital before they bleed to death) putting out fires before people burn to death . You can also drive people around in a taxi and be a vigilante. I know the vigilante part would actually be illegal but maybe its less evil to kill fake criminals than it is to kill fake civilians ...who knows??

Tim 's picture

First,I must say that I love

First,I must say that I love to play video games both violent and nonviolent.
Now on to the fun part. Let's pretend for a second that all the people that have blamed music, movies, and games for violent acts were actually telling the truth." The game made me do it!!!" etc.
Well ok then lets ban all of it..... or we could just burn it all ( I've heard that works really well on books also)
Okay, all the bad things are gone , right??? No!
Give it time and there will be another kid going to school and killing other kids. So, what is it going to be this time?? " The toaster made me do it.." Hey why not a microwave.
No, it was the neighbor's dog..( For those of you who remember the Son of Sam)
Back to reality.... The stuff about Doom being a form of training for Marines made me laugh a bit. I am not sure about the PC version but the one i have for playstation has auto-aim always turned on..I Really hope it does train Marines so well that they don't have to aim at all .

Anonymous's picture

I have to wonder.....

I have to wonder, sometimes, if the people who write papers such as this have ever even picked up a controller. I used to have major anger management issues. When I started playing video games, they helped me vent this anger in a positive way, rather than invoking violent acts on living beings. I am now a more stable person, calmer and less snippy than I used to be- because when I get angry, I simply sit down and play a fighting game, or something similar. In a way, playing violent video games is not so different from taking martial arts to calm your mind- yet another thing I practice.

For those of you who worry for the innocent minds of children, as many have stated before me, it is up to a parent to decide if their child is mature enough to handle a violent game- that is why games have a rating system. If you don't let your child watch an R rated film, don't let them pick up an M rated game. It is that simple. In all honesty, most of the cartoons children are raised on- especially these days- are worse than many of the games they play. Maybe parents should monitor the shows their children watch on Saturday mornings before they judge video games. And perhaps those who have never played before should stop their senseless, harsh judgement, and pick up a controller- then watch as their stress melts away.

Lindsey says......'s picture

Come on it's true!

yah know what who cares about what you haters say. I believe that it causes violence and since when is it okay to watch people die, or kill people electronically or not it still sends the message that violent acts are okay and that It's fun and a game to kill. So you guys who say "yeah I'm not violent, but I've played this since .... years" you guys have issues.

MA-39's picture

Violence In Games

To one who states things with so little regard, let me just say this: as a gamer, yes I get a few laughs out of violent games. Some death scenes are funny. It's sort of like you watching the violence in cartoons (or didn't you notice those portray violence to our kids?)and getting a giggle out of that. That does not mean me and the vast majority of gamers who feel the same way would burst into a laugh riot if we saw someone get masacred in the street. We wouldn't stand back and shout "Ooo! Ten points!" and point and jeer. We'd go help, you know, like normal people. If you want to bash video games, at least state your case better. And if you truly believe that video games make you violent, then go check the stats. Maybe you should bash instead those cute little cartoons you grew up on. You know, those ones you've been watching for ...years? To be honest, just by reading your statement, you're the one with issues. The gamer society and I are just fine, and the world will be a lot better off with us in it, rather than those who state opinions as facts and really don't know what they're talking about, nor care to go even somewhat in-depth with it. And to all those who support the "oh no, video game violence, dear god it's an epidemic" theory, get over yourselves. Pay more attention to what really matters in society and stop trying to rain on the sane peoples' parade.
I realize I might be posting this a little late, but by all means, I invite anyone to challenge me on this. All I have to say is if you do, you'd best be a defense attorney for your theories, because I will make you face the reality you refuse to acknowledge. As a true gamer, I offer you this statement: Bring. It. On.

Anonymous's picture

you are the one who cant

you are the one who cant dechipher the video from the game you need to stop being he "hater" and stop pointing fingers at something that is taking the blame for bad parenting get over it